At the Center
Capturing the lively discussions, presentations, and other events that make up the daily activities of the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University.
Thursday, Sep. 19, 2013 2:12 PM
A new software engineering ethics teaching module from the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics has the blogosphere talking about the need for ethics education for engineers. An article in Pacific Standard, later reposted in Slate, picked up on the work of Center Internet Ethics Director Irina Raicu to develop ethics curricula that can be slipped into courses in engineering. As she told Pacific Standard, software engineers used to work in big companies where they had checks on the choices they made. 'Now, we’re talking about two guys in hoodies in a garage,' Raicu said. They deploy the code now and fix it later. 'That’s why we need to get them thinking about this early.'"
The module for software engineers was created by SCU Associate Professor of Philosophy Shannon Vallor with special contributions from Arvind Narayanan, assistant professor of computer science,Princeton University. Narayanan also raised the issue on the blog Freedom to Tinker, where he asked engineers to submit ethical issues they had confronted in their work.
Wednesday, Sep. 18, 2013 9:50 AM
Sally Lehrman has been named senior fellow in journalism ethics at the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics. Formerly the the Knight Ridder Professor in Journalism and the Public Interest at SCU, Lehrman will continue convening the Executive Roundtable on Digital Journalism Ethics, which she started in collaboration with the Center in 2008. Her work has focused on medical and science policy reporting and on diversity in the newsroom.
Friday, Sep. 13, 2013 1:16 PM
The moment has come in the Mass for the readings. You look down the row as the reader begins a passage from Malachi or Thessalonians or Luke. Are the children listening raptly to the word of God? More likely they are squirming in the pew, poking a younger sibling, whispering, or daydreaming. The biblical language and concepts have left them behind.
But it doesn’t have to be that way. Steve Johnson, director of character education at Santa Clara University’s Markkula Center for Applied Ethics, says these ancient texts can speak very directly to kids—with the help of the Center’s new faith formation program, Build. Plant. Grow.
The curriculum pairs the Sunday readings with a classic children’s book and uses both to highlight a virtue that anyone can practice.
Build. Plant. Grow. takes its title from a passage in Jeremiah:
Build houses and live in them; plant gardens and eat what they produce...multiply there and do not decrease. But seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile, and pray to the Lord on its behalf, for in its welfare, you will find your welfare.
According to Johnson, the curriculum “is a faith formation program for people of any age who build, plant, and grow the word in their lives. It’s especially for use in schools and parishes as children break open the word each week.” The online curriculum
provides weekly lesson plans that suggest how people can, as Johnson puts it, “live our daily lives as Christians at our best.”
An illustration: The lesson plan for the third Sunday in September looks at the value of compassion in Horton Hears a Who by Dr. Seuss and a passage from the Gospel of St. Luke, which includes the story of the good shepherd who goes in search of one lost sheep. Participants—both young and old—are encouraged to care for every each individual regardless of their status—as Horton puts it, “A person’s a person no matter how small.” The curriculum then asks how caring and compassion can be put into action by, for example, providing items for distribution to the needy at the St. Vincent de Paul Society.
Anthony Mancuso, S.J., chaplain at St. Francis High School in Mountain View, Calif., wrote many of the lesson plans for Build. Plant. Grow. “I took the readings for each Sunday and pulled out a connection between them, often a word related to a virtue, such as justice or courage,” he said. Mancuso tied that idea to a children’s book dealing with the same theme, which “allows the ethics to come alive for a younger mind.” The lesson plans also offer hands-on activities, with different approaches sensitive to the different ways children learn. Another section, called “What can I do today?” asks children to take concrete actions based on the virtue they’re learning about. Finally, the lesson concludes with a prayer.
Build. Plant. Grow. is intended for use by Catholic school and parish religion teachers and by parents who want to engage young people in the Gospel message in a way that is relevant and vital.
Friday, Sep. 13, 2013 11:40 AM
Father Thomas Reese, SJ, Markkula Center Visiting Scholar and Senior Analyst, National Catholic Reporter, provided humor, inspiration, and savvy commentary on "all things Pope Francis" during the September 12th Ethics at Noon session, entertaining and informing the lunchtime crowd of 80 attendants.
What's in a name? Pope Francis is known for his simplicity, love of the poor and of Creation, and as a celebrant of peace and interreligious understanding. Indeed his first actions are best defined as "simple:" paying his hotel bill, refusing to live in the papal apartments, driving a Ford instead of a Mercedes, and washing the feet of prisoners. As Archbishop of Buenos Aires, he cooked his own meals and took the bus over limousines. We can almost refer to him as the "cold call Pope," who is not afraid to make his own phone calls and request a direct connection to "he Jesuit switchboard."
And yet, Reese's excellent grasp of the Pope's positions reveal complexity behind the simplicity, and a real ability for both Reese and the Pope, to call it like they see it. For example, the Pope's pastoral priorities conjure a church of the heart, that serves as both reconciler and conduit for justice, charity, and love. His priorities for Bishops include increased involvement of women in the church, a rediscovery of "mercy," and a proactive and entrepreneurial mindset.
Following are additional key soundbytes and questions from the presentation:
- We are a church of symbols, and this is how we communicate
- On sexual abuse: zero tolerance
- Celibacy: "it's a matter of discipline, not faith. It can change."
- The Appointment of Bishops: they should be close to the people, as well as gentle, patient, as merciful.
No princes. "Shepherds should smell like their sheep."
- Denying Communion: One can deny communio to a sinner, "but it's very difficult to check such things."
- The Church: Are we still capable of warming hearts? "I prefer a church that makes mistakes because it is doing something, to one that sickens because it remains shut in."
- On The Vatican and Change: Don't make curia officials bishops or cardinals; call for separation of legislative, executive, and judicial power; Vatican needs to become a modern bureaucracy.
Formerly the editor of America magazine, Reese is the author of a trilogy examining Catholic Church organization and politics on the local, national, and international levels: Archbishop: Inside the Power Structure of the American Catholic Church (Harper & Row, 1989), A Flock of Shepherds: The National Conference of Catholic Bishops (Sheed & Ward , 1992), and Inside the Vatican: The Politics and Organization of the Catholic Church (Harvard University Press, 1997). Reese is a frequent commentator for national news outlets such as NPR, and major news networks.
MORE: Listen to the podcast here.
Thursday, Sep. 12, 2013 3:00 PM
Center Executive Director Kirk O. Hanson introduced Jim Thompson, founder and chief executive of the Positive Coaching Alliance, at today's Sports Law and Ethics Symposium. Thompson will be giving a featured presentation on "What We Can Learn From What Happened at Rutgers," where Head Coach of the men's basketball team Mike Rice was fired for mentally and physically abusing players.
Thompson is the first recipient of the ETHOS Award for contributions to the positive role of sport in American life, sponsored by SCU's Institute of Sports Law and Ethics. Hanson sits on the Institute Board and co-chairs the ETHOS Award Committee.
Tuesday, Sep. 3, 2013 3:55 PM
The Center is pleased to welcome James O'Toole, as senior fellow in business ethics. O'Toole will work with the Center's Business and Organizational Ethics Partnership and on projects related to leadership. Previously he was the Daniels Distinguished Professor of Business Ethics at the University of Denver's Daniels College of Business. While at the University of Southern California's business school for two decades, he held the University Associates' Chair of Management, served as Executive Director of the Leadership Institute, and was editor of New Management magazine. From 1994-97 O'Toole was Executive Vice President of the Aspen Institute, and later, Mortimer J. Adler Senior Fellow at the Institute. He also has served as Chair of the Booz/Allen/Hamilton Strategic Leadership Center.
Among O'Toole's sixteen books, Vanguard Management was named "one of the best business and economics books of 1985" by the editors of Business Week. His latest book is Good Business (editor, with Don Mayer, 2010). He currently writes a bi-weekly blog for Strategy+Business magazine.
O'Toole received his doctorate in Social Anthropology from Oxford University, where he was a Rhodes Scholar.
Friday, Aug. 30, 2013 10:36 AM
"Since they accept charitable gifts, nonprofits are increasingly in the spotlight and face greater scrutiny and accountability then ever before," agreed the presenters during the "Ethical Dilemmas and Nonprofits" panel held on August 20, and sponsored by The Markkula Ethics Center, AFP (Association of Fundraising Professionals-Silicon Valley), and Focus Bank.
Moderator Ervie Smith, representing Focus Business Bank, led panelists through a lively and informative series of ethical questions and scenarios commonly facing nonprofit communities, well received by the audience of 80 association leaders. Featured panelists were: Brian Adams, Bellarmine College Prep Christian Service Program; Judith Kleinberg, Knight Foundation; and Peter Hero, The Hero Group.
One of the ethical scenarios involved the issue of "giving for a gift," a real life case study in which a parent alumnus offers a donation to a school in return for his child's admission. "Any strings attached to a gift is a major red flag. In this scenario, simply do not accept the gift."
Another scenario involved "interpretive" staff trips and expenses. For example, your job requires matching expense reports with receipts, and you find that while some staff were cautious and thrifty spenders, others took cabs, enjoyed room service, and helped themselves to the allure of the hotel "mini bar. "
"First, there must be clear and ironclad rules regarding business travel expenses detailed in the employee handbook, so that there is one standard for all staff," the panelists commented. "Second, confront those who did the gratuitous spending, offer them opportunity to explain, but make them accountable. They need to know there will be consequences to this behavior."
Other highlights included:
- Examples of ethical issues include: conflicts of interest, plagiarism, invasion of privacy, bias, and deceit or lack of transparency
- Donors want nonprofits to succeed, and organizations should be transparent if they're facing financial stresses that challenge a grant's purpose
- If a nonprofit is dishonest or fails to be transparent, its reputation is jeopardized
- There is great importance in the donor-institution connection...it's all about relationships
- Fundraising staff need to understand the mission of the organization and ultimately protect the brand
Tuesday, Aug. 27, 2013 10:26 AM
Pictured in photo are panelists from the ethics of working from home session: Kristin Major, Hewlett-Packard, Patty Woolcock, California Strategic Human Resrouce Partnership, Laura Maechtlen, Seyfarth Shaw LLP, and Eric Severson, Gap, Inc.
The Ethics Center presented its quarterly "Business and Organizational Ethics Partnership" (BOEP) Roundtable on Thursday, August 22, providing attendees with plenty of food for thought on prominent issues in business ethics.
After greetings and introductions by Jim Balassone, the Center's Executive-in-Residence, the morning agenda included the following program highlights: thought-provoking ethical case studies, presented by Jim O'Toole, Senior Fellow in Business Ethics; "Multitasking: The Short and Long-term Effects on Ethics and Business," presented by Clifford Nass, Professor of Communications, Stanford University; and "Economic, Ethical, and Legal Attributes of Working from Home," presented by Kristin Major, VP and Deputy GC, Hewlett-Packard, Eric Severson, SVP, HR, The Gap, and Laura Macctlen, Sayfarth Shaw, moderated by Patty Woolcock, Executive Director, CSHRP. Afternoon sessions included "You Can Make Money Without Doing Evil," presented by Andy Hinton, Ethics and Compliance Officer, Google; and "Transforming an Organization's Ethical Culture," presented by Greg Coplans, EVP Corporate Affairs,
Hitachi Data Systems.
Takeaways and soundbytes from two of the sessions, the ethical effects on multitasking and working from home, respectively, include:
*Today, the average college student uses 3 forms of media at once.
*For the past 20 years, studies have shown that multitasking impedes performance. focus, memory, problem-solving ability, and social interaction
*The 20-minute rule - meaning focusing on one task for at least that time, can help control the task management challenge.
*The Gap Inc. makes for an interesting case study in ROWE (results-oriented work environment), which showed increased productivity, communication, and quality of work, after implementation.
*Some of the challenges involved with allowing employees to work at home or from other locations, include increased and more formalized communications on work-related issues, such as email response time and equipment needs,
and trained and active managers who can effectily oversee these scenarios.
*In the near future, working from home will become increasingly commonplace, particularly with the continuing evolution and sophistication of technology and communications.
Thursday, Aug. 22, 2013 3:09 PM
The Solar Decathlon Team is
Ready for the Competition!
Markkula Center for Applied Ethics Environmental Ethics Fellows Melissa Giorgi (top) and Allie Sibole
The Solar Decathlon "Send Off" event held on Monday, August 19, was a great success, as Santa Clara University students involved in the construction of "Radiant House" gave tours of their nearly completed net-zero home, to staff, colleagues, press, and fellow students. The project, part of the U.S. Dept. of Energy's national Solar Decathlon Competition, has become one of the hallmark's of Santa Clara University's sustainability programs, and participation in recent years has produced impressive results, including placements in the top winner's group. Unique features of this year's home include innovative uses of bamboo, and the first-time use of Sunplanter, which eliminates separate solar racking and roof structure systems by combining them into one innovative technology. In two weeks, the home will be broken down into three sections and transported to The Great Park in Irvine, Orange County, CA, for the final competition.
Two Markkula Center Environmental Ethics Fellows, Allie Sibole and Melissa Giorgi, played important roles in the evolution of the Solar Decathlon project this year. Sibole wrote a report, "Material Evaluation Sheets: Ethical Considerations for Selecting Building Materials," which explores the ethical implications of various building materials. In "The Sun and the City: Making Solar Power More Accessible," Melissa Giorgi explores making solar installations more affordable for low-income populations.
New! SCU would love for Bill Nye to come check out Radiant House, and created a clever video explaining the reasons why...go team!
Thursday, Aug. 22, 2013 1:36 PM
Not every legal action a government official may take is also ethical. Law provides a floor of minimum standards, but public officials who are concerned with ethics may want to go beyond what is simply legal when they consider how to act in the public interest.
The interaction of law and ethics was explored at the August 2013 meeting of the Center's Public Sector Roundtable by panelists Joan Cassman, partner with Hanson Bridgett L.L.P. in San Francisco, and JoAnne Speers, executive director of the Institute for Local Government in Sacramento.